Post by erich on Mar 11, 2013 11:11:53 GMT -5
I don’t usually gripe about customer service -in fact, my
experience with firearms-related customer service - and reloading related
customer service in particular - have been very good. But I had a bad
experience with Federal just now, and thought I’d share it, because it was so
unusual in relation to the service I’ve gotten on other ammunition issues.
So, yesterday I had brought a brand-new silver box of
Federal Classic ammo to the range to try in my new-to-me pre-Model 30 Improved
I-frame. The Federal Classic ammo was 98-gr RNL .32 S&W Long, part no.
C32LB, lot number 3 19J155. Federal ammo is more expensive in this caliber than
Eastern European stuff, but I figured the good thing about using big maker ammo
from Federal would be that I’d be able to reload the empties. Based on decades
of past experience, I figured I’d get quality brass after firing the
low-pressure .32 S&W Long factory loads.
The ammo shot well enough (group at 10 yards), though was
pretty tame (M 667.8/ES 78.95/SD 32.31).
But wait! Upon firing, I noticed that one round did a very
odd spurt of stuff out of the bbl/cyl gap, and was surprised to find that I had
to hammer
ejector rod to get the rounds out of the cylinder. Out of five rounds, four
split - and one had its primer pop out the back.[/p]
This was NOT the fault of the gun - I fired four other
loadings on the same outing (two handloads - ironically in Federal cases, and
two factory loadings by S&B and Aguila) with no problems whatsoever.
So, since this ammo wasn’t going to give me the reloadable
cases that I’d been after, I figured I’d contact ATK; on advice of friend, I
went to their site and filled out a contact form:
Federal Classic .32 S&W Long ammo, part no. C32LB, lot number 3 19J155. One
primer protruded. The cases had to be forcibly extracted by hammering the
ejector rod. This was not a problem with the gun, as several other loadings
performed flawlessly.
Here are some photographs:
i225.photobucket.com/albums/dd222/505Erich/Handguns/2013-03-10_11-34-34_709.jpg
i225.photobucket.com/albums/dd222/505Erich/Handguns/2013-03-10_11-34-51_820.jpg
I deliberately purchased what I thought to be quality Federal ammo because I
wanted the spent cases for reloading. Please contact me about this.
I was really surprised when Federal wrote back a terse, “Go
Away” email:
shelf. The brass split due to stress corrosion cracking. It was manufactured in
2003.
Thanks
Federal Ammunition
I was pretty amazed by this, and responded:
me? I've been happily reloading much of the same brass since the '80s, and
you're going to tell me that your new, never-fired brass from only ten years
ago will split when fired in a low-pressure factory loading in the .32
S&W Long cartridge.
I’ve not heard back. I’m not pleased with Federal/ATK’s
handling of the situation; I would have expected that Federal/ATK would stand
behind its products or care more about its customers.